Monday, March 8, 2010

Beware Those Attractive Supplements

OK guys! I am the first to say that we need supplements. First of all, there are not enough nutrients in the food we purchase and even if there was, because of the busy and stressful life we lead we need more help. For instance, have a cold, take more vitamin C; get older and have joint problems: take glucosamine, fish oils and calcium. These sorts of things.

It goes bad when people, from a genuine desire to help themselves and take responsibility for their own health, are taken in by wonderfully marketed products which are inevitably wrapped in very attractive packaging and which contain? CRAP!! Crap! crap! crap!

I've just spent almost an hour checking and rechecking the products a patient of mine has been taking (obviously if she's just become a patient of mine, she hasn't had much result from them) and my mind has been boggling and my blood has been boiling. Good thing I take the right nutrients.

For instance: a supplement which is meant to be full of antioxidants contains a piddly 500 micrograms of Lycopene. Now if you get one medium size tomato, you will absorb 2000 more time Lycopene. Even tomato sauce out of a bottle has hundreds of times more Lycopene per teaspoon!

Her calcium supplement (and we all know how calcium supplements are important to us who are no longer 30); well, that calcium supplement was made of calcium citrate and calcium carbonate. Both really cheap and calcium carbonate practically impossible to absorb by the human digestive tract; calcium carbonate is only good as a buffer for other supplements. What's good about them? They are cheap! Oh, no! Not cheap to you silly! Cheap to the manufacturer. Here it is: I buy calcium carbonate for my chickens (i would not give it to my horses or dogs or humans) and it costs me $13/ 5 kilos. But if you are a manufacturer and you buy it by the ton, it will only cost a few cents per kilo. Cheap indeed, but for whom? Of course someone has to pay for all the marketing and the shiny labels. Silly me!

So what to do?

First of all, avoid what i call: "kitchen sink formulae" all these 'nutrients' packed in a little pill are usually in amounts too small to be effective. Also a lot of them are antagonistic to each other; for instance if a supplement contains iron and vitamin E, then you won't get either, because iron and E make an insoluble compound that your body cannot absorb. Zinc should be taken on its own because most nutrients are antagonist to zinc.

I could go on but i won't. Just remember that when you take supplements 'simple' is the best and get the opinion of a qualified naturopath and if the naturopath gives you a 'kitchen sink' supplement, find another naturopath.

And now i'll go and take some anti-high blood pressure supplement in the form of a cup of lemon verbena tea. (although i would prefer a gin and tonic ;o) and i'm going to have a large dose of anti-oxidants in the shape of a punnet of bluberries.

1 comment:

  1. You go EL!!!!!! Soooooo true on the supplement subject. As you put in your books.......very expensive pee........I have basically put it down as, if you can "self - diagnose" and buy it off the shelf, it has to be so low in active ingredient so as not to cause any major harm in the consumer, otherwise it is lawsuits all round....It is the same in the beauty industry (which thankfully I have no part in anylonger - my concience will not allow it) If you can buy any beauty product off the shelf without a doctor or beauty therapist "prescription" it WILL be full of crap, fillers, colours etc to make you think it is doing what it says on the packaging.
    I wonder if most people know that the manufacturers behind beauty/cosmetics and "health" products are all owned by the same big corporations. That's right, whether you prefer one supplement brand to another or one beauty product to another, if you do your homework, you will find almost ALL of them are owned by the SAME company.

    Love peace and truth to all,
    Kim xxx

    ReplyDelete